ScienceStuff
From bombs to black holes - get your daily science fix right here.

Category RSS Feed

PETA to UGA: Get a Robot Dawg, Morons

by Robert Lamb |

7 Comments | Add Comment

 

go dawgs?

Robot dogs? College football? Might the worlds of Doctor Who worship and mainstream sports fandom finally be converging? (Evening Standard/Hulton Archive/Getty Images)

Last week I reported on the sad passing of the University of Georgia’s Uga VII. The 4-year-old English bulldog had been bred to encourage its most outrageous features — features that, when exaggerated, can interfere with little things like breathing oxygen and perpetuating the species through mating.

Now, according the the L.A. Times, the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) has entered the fray, demanding that UGA turn to costumed mascots or, yes, robot dogs instead of subjecting the poor bulldog to hot, humid football games.

As I’m writing this post in the state of Georgia, I can already hear the outrage of football fans rise up from the streets and hills. Let’s face it: PETA isn’t exactly on good terms with the average red-blooded American. The only common ground I can think of is the public display of naked models. Otherwise, PETA hates barbeque, fast food, hunting and fishing. Now it’s coming after American Football. The outrage!

I’d be lying if I said I agreed with PETA on every stance it takes, but then again, its whole protest strategy is based on gaining maximum publicity through, well, ire-raising stunts such as this. Plus, sometimes you have to push for extreme change in order to achieve moderate improvements.

Of course, UGA already has a costumed mascot named Hairy Dog (which looks a lot like a Moblin) they could depend more on. And we have plenty of robot K9s, dinosaurs and even humanoids to fall back on. Surely we can program a little college football zeal into these fine machines? And, as I previously stated, I’m also a huge fan of simply breeding our dogs to be healthy as opposed to meeting our selfish and ridiculous criteria. Remember, there was a time when the English bulldog was a trim, sleek animal with a purpose in life other than helping a crowd attach its ego to a game of catch.

But then again, I’m not a football fan. What do you fans think about PETA’s proposal?

Thanks to HSW’s Sarah Dowdey for pointing this development out to me!

EDIT: I should also point out that a 2008 study conducted at NHC HealthCare in Maryland Heights, Mo., found that the robotic dog Aibo was just as effective at decreasing human loneliness as a living, breathing dog. If robots are up to the task of keeping our old people happy, then might they also be just as capable of leading a sports team to victory? Think about it, won’t you?

“Go Dawgs” or Something at HowStuffWorks.com:
How Animal Domestication Works
How American Football Works
How Dogs Work
How Protest Works
How Robots Work
Football Mascot Uga VII Bites the Dust: Breeding to blame?

 

Tags: , , , , ,

7 Comments

  • Devin B says:

    I think that animal breeders can breed animals any way they want. If every time someone bred an animal and it wasn’t prefectly suited to be healthy, then we would have practically none of the breeds we have today. We wouldn’t have large dogs, because they don’t live as long, or really small dogs, because they don’t have a lot of mobility, and we wouldn’t have ugly dogs because they are less likely to be adopted than regular dogs. This is just another PETA publicity stunt, and I am very doubtful that the University is going to change their mascot.

  • Robert Lamb says:

    If the choice is between breeding an animal to encourage health and encouraging physical features that make us giggle or smile, I think there’s only one ethical choice. I once worked with a woman who openly admitted to smoking during her pregnancy in order to birth a smaller, cuter child for the purposes of entering the kid in child beauty contests. For my money, these are two arrows from the same quiver of self-centered arrogance.

    ~rl

  • Katie Lambert says:

    I am a Dawg fan, and I agree that responsible breeding is important. I’ve met too many purebred dogs (goldens, in particular) with serious health problems.

    I will say that Uga spends most of the game in an air-conditioned doghouse with a bag of ice. For a dog, he has it good.

    PETA will get no attention from me until they stop using naked women to make their points.

  • Robert Lamb says:

    The AC & bag of ice deal makes me wonder about the possibility of cryogenicly preserved mascots. As long as we’re forced to create artificial environments so that our bred-to-order pets can survive typical Earth weather, then why not?

    And true enough, I can’t recall ever seeing anything from PETA that didn’t depend on either gory images or nudity.

    ~rl

  • Katie Lambert says:

    I’d rather be in his climate-controlled doghouse than in the stands on a mercilessly hot Georgia September Saturday. Hot, humid weather: also difficult for humans.

  • Robert Lamb says:

    I should also point out that the dog wears a little shirt, just so anyone wandering into this post gets a clear picture of the overall absurdity here.

    ~rl

  • Amy says:

    I hadn’t heard about this. I looked a bit at the history of the Ugas (here: http://www.georgiadogs.com/ViewArticle.dbml?SPSID=48586&SPID=4107&DB_OEM_ID=8800&ATCLID=454891) and it’s amazing how much the line of dogs have changed in appearance. Uga II looks like a far leaner, healthier dog than Uga VII. I hate to find myself agreeing with PETA, but I feel really bad for the poor dogs.

Add your comment

Facebook Users

or Non-Facebook Users

Please read our comment policy »

We love thoughtful responses and lively debates in our comment threads, but please be polite and keep your comments on topic. Spam, trolling, profanity, threats, personal attacks or comments that are generally considered not safe for work will be deleted. For more information please see our Visitor Agreement

Recent Postings by Category