Stuff You Should Know
The digital duo Josh and Chuck deconstruct your world.
The Effects of Music on the Human Psyche: From Empathy to Hostility to Sleep Deprivation
by Josh Clark | November 10, 2009

Boy George commands you to contribute money to alleviate starvation in Africa! (Dave Hogan/Getty Images)
Music has a real effect on us. Why, I’m listening to music right now (Devo) and it’ll probably help shape this post. Case in point: There’s a new study out in the journal Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin that covers how songs with prosocial lyrics have a prosocial impact on its listeners. Take, for instance, “Do They Know It’s Christmas?” Remember Band Aid? The all-star group recorded that song 25 years ago to raise money for famine-stricken African nations. And it worked; the single raised over 8 million pounds. That’s pretty prosocial. Same goes for songs like “We Are the World” and “Hands Across America.”
These songs represent the most bluntly overt prosocial lyrics, of course. But other prosocial songs, like just about anything recorded in the late 60s, also have a similar effect. And the study in the Bulletin concluded that these songs affect us by stimulating our senses of interpersonal empathy. We hear about the little kid dying of starvation in Ethiopia, circa 1984, and we are moved to action. It makes sense; we didn’t walk around thinking about starving Ethiopians generally over here in the U.S. It took a call to action to move us to action.
The 8 million pounds raised by Band Aid reveals media’s impact on us. Not all songs are prosocial; there are plenty of songs out there that qualify as antisocial. Does the converse of prosocial lyrics’ effect on our empathy hold true? Do antisocial songs spur antisocial behavior? It would appear that way. There’s been even more research on the effects of antisocial lyrics. One of the earlier studies of this ilk (1992) examined the effect of hard rock and rap on the behavior of mental patients at a state hospital. Patients in two groups were exposed to a steady diet of hard rock and rap for 21 days or just as lengthy exposure to easy listening and country and Western. Lo and behold, the patients who listened to hard rock and rap showed more inappropriate behavior than the cowboys and Kenny Loggins.
That study and other like it have spurred investigations into and indictments of music and video games and anything else that might be turning kids into little deviants, because of course it couldn’t be disengaged parents or poorly-operated public schools or a diet consisting of 90 percent HFCS. Much of the research has come to the same conclusion: music with antisocial lyrics (starring rap!) fosters antisocial behavior. I’m not necessarily disputing this, having accidentally brainwashed myself as a teenager listening to Snoop Dogg’s Doggystyle relentlessly for several consecutive weeks. My point is there’s not a lot that can be done about it, what with that pesky First Amendment. Ask Luther Campbell and 2 Live Crew.
The powerful effect music can have on the human psyche isn’t lost on law enforcement and the military. Interestingly, both groups have concluded that music can also be used as a form of torture — especially depending on the song. In standoffs and secret prisons around the world, songs you know and hate and maybe love have made an appearance to create sleep deprivation, intimidation and just generally drive people nuts. I was sent a list of music used as torture (thanks for the link, LOML): In the Waco standoff with the Branch Davidians, the FBI played Mitch Miller’s entire album, “Christmas Sing-Along With Mitch.” At Guantanamo, detainees are treated to Barney’s theme song, “I Love You” and the Meow Mix jingle. Over. And Over. And Over. Rick Astley’s “Never Gonna Give You Up,” was played during the standoff outside Manuel Noriega’s mansion in Panama. David Gray’s “Babylon” was on regular rotation at Abu Ghraib. It just goes on like this.
Here’s the complete list of songs used as instruments of torture around the world. Pretty neat.
More on HowStuffWorks.com:
Is there a link between music and happiness?
Does contagious yawning mean you’re nice?
Was there a covert CIA prison system?
-
Of all the people in the world, I never suspected that I would get RickRolled by Josh Clark. Part of me has died a little bit…..
-
Great post, Josh, as always. This has me interested. I’ve decided to write a song called “I want to give Rob all my money” and hand it out as a holiday gift. Now if I can only get Rick Astley to record it….
-
I’m willing to overlook the rickroll in light of the knowledge you have imparted on me – Noriega got rickrolled? Badassery. Keep up the excellence, and start watching It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia, Josh – I mean it!
-
I was listening to Dr. Dre oustide near an ant hill one time. The ants then tried to attack me, so I killed them. Think of all the ant lives that could have been saved if only I’d been listening to Enya.
-
That was the most epic rickroll ever. kudos to you!
-
Ugh, Robert Lamb, listening to that was like having bleach in my eyes. Interesting nonetheless though.
-
You win this time Mr. Clark…You win this time.
Also to Mr. Lamb, the song was actually quite palatable until the operapper stopped spitting fat beats.
-
I know Trent Reznor was pretty pissed that Nine Inch Nails music was used as torture at Guantanamo, but I wonder if he would mind the Rickrolled NIN being used. God knows, it’s enough to make me want to spill my guts…
-
Josh. This is a proclamation of my love for you. you have the most adorable voice and the biggest brain! I listen to your podcast daily. I love hearing you talk about dead stuff and face transplants. You make me smarter! lets be real friends. I am only sort of a psycho. But I am a nice enough girl.
-Susan.
Recent Postings by Category
BrainStuff
- Interesting Reading #414 – The tiniest computer, hearts really can break, family pays $5,000 per year for connections, New font saves ink and much more…
- Public Service Announcement – Soft drinks nearly double your chances of pancreatic cancer
- Amazing – Going inside the Giant Crystal Cave
FanStuff
- What’s art — and what’s groundbreaking — in video games?
- Ursula K. Le Guin vs. Google Books: Round Two
- “Lost,” “Fringe” and That Whole Alternate Universe Thing
How-to Stuff
- How to Take a Road Trip, Abraham Lincoln-Style
- How to Explain Love in the Least Romantic Way Possible
- How to Quiet a Barking Dog
ScienceStuff
- Space Music Vol. 8: Sun Ra and Afrofuturism
- Stuff from the Science Lab Roundup: Space Eats and Grow Houses
- Why does time fly as you get older?
Stuff You Should Know
The Coolest Stuff on the Planet
High Speed Stuff
- The Toyota Recall: Where can you get the latest information?
- What is Toyota doing to fix its gas pedal problem?
- High Speed Stuff Wrap-up: Automotive Pet Peeves and Polar Vehicles
Keep Asking
- How does an airbrush work?
- Is the Internet free? If you want to make a website, will it cost you to put it online?
- If you look at a piece of glass from an angle, why does it have a bluish or green tint?
Stuff You Missed in History Class
- Last Week in History Podcasts: Battle Horses and Black Moses
- The Wonderful Adventures of the Nurse We Forgot
- Black History Month on HowStuffWorks



11 Comments